The Roman Catholic Diocese of Wheeling-Charleston, West
Virginia recently announced its former bishop has been sanctioned by the
Vatican. The bishop was accused of
sexual and financial misconduct. I will leave the sexual misconduct issues to
others, but I do want to look at the financial misconduct issues purely from an
NFP management perspective.
As part of the sanctions, the bishop was ordered not to live
in the diocese. Effectively, this means
he will need to leave the State of West Virginia since the Wheeling-Charleston
diocese encompasses the entire state. He has been prohibited from conducting
public religious celebrations and will need to make restitution. [1] That sounded good so far, but I was waiting
for more.
Any organization facing a crisis needs to do three critical
things: fix the problem, prevent the
problem from reoccurring, and be transparent.
While the Vatican fixed the problem by removing the bishop from office
and instituting new internal controls in the diocese there was no discussion of
how this particular person was selected to be a bishop, why the Vatican took so
long to respond to warnings,[2]
and what it is going to do to prevent this from happening again. In short, its
response seemed dramatic but lacked essential elements of proper management.
Perhaps the Vatican made nal improvements it did not announce. Even so, that would fail the transparency
requirement. Constituencies are
forgiving but they like to know this won’t reoccur. The bishop’s successor has already been criticized
as being a good man but not the right person for the job.[3] I can only wish him luck.
Lest anyone should think this is an isolated incident, the
Vatican also reinstalled a major archbishop (effectively equivalent to an
Eastern Orthodox patriarch) in India who also had been accused of financial
mismanagement. In this case, the major
archbishop entered into a real estate transaction that resulted in an
inexplicable loss. There were no reasons
given what the result of the Vatican investigation was. As a result, there have been major protests
against his reinstatement. [4]
All this could have been avoided if the Vatican followed simple principles of
management.
Not-For-Profits everywhere,
let this be a lesson. Remember:
fix the problem, make sure it doesn’t reoccur, and be transparent about
how it occurred.
[1] https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2019/07/19/pope-francis-issues-disciplinary-measures-bishop-bransfield
Accessed July 25,
[2] https://www.americamagazine.org/faith/2019/06/12/explainer-how-could-bishop-bransfield-misuse-funds-years-without-raising-red-flags Accessed July 26, 2019
[3] http://whispersintheloggia.blogspot.com/
Accessed July 25, 2019
[4] https://cruxnow.com/church-in-asia/2019/07/24/catholic-priests-in-india-protest-cardinals-return/
Accessed July 21, 2019